Find the Real Cost of Payroll: Why Most Builders Are Off by Up to 30%

Tax-Saving Video Series · With Samy Basta, CPA

In this episode, Samy explains why payroll is never just wages. He tells the story of a $3.6 million concrete contractor in the Central Valley who believed payroll ran about $95,000 a month, until the real number came in at about $115,500, a gap worth $246,000 of profit a year that never existed. Then he shares the one number every builder should know, labor burden, and three steps to put it to work.

Jump to: Episode insights · The three steps · Carlos’s payroll

Lightly edited for readability: speech-to-text errors corrected, wording unchanged.

 

Last year, I had a client who thought he was making good money. $3.6 million in revenue, always busy, always slammed. But his bank account told a different story. His cash was always tight, and he complained. So we dug in, and we found $246,000 of profit that didn’t exist. It wasn’t a mistake. It wasn’t theft. It was a pure surprise, hidden inside numbers he never looked at. Let me show you how you find yours.

 

I’m Samy Basta. I’m a CPA. I run Basta & Company, San Francisco based. We work with builders all across California. And in the next seven minutes, I want to show you the real cost of your payroll and the one number that fixes everything for you.

 

Here’s the truth. Most builders look at payroll and see only one line. It’s called wages. That’s it. But payroll is not just wages. Payroll is wages plus employer taxes plus benefits plus workers’ comp plus reimbursements plus overtime plus all that random stuff that gets buried in your books.

 

Think about it. It’s like ordering a pizza. You think it costs $20, right? But by the time delivery, tips, and all the toppings you didn’t order get added up, it’s about $40. Same thing with payroll. You think you spent $70,000 this month. You actually spent $90,000, sometimes more.

 

So let me give you the math straight up. If your gross wages are, let’s say, $70,000, your real cost is probably somewhere around $85,000 to $91,000. That’s a 15 to 30% gap. Most builders never see it because their books mix everything together. Office wages mixed with field wages. Health insurance coded differently every month. Workers’ comp buried in a random account. So the reports look fine, but they’re not telling you the real story. The reports are fiction.

 

You want a quick test? Here’s what you need to do. Take your gross wages this month. Multiply that number by 1.2. If that number shocks you, if it makes you uncomfortable, there you go. You just found why cash feels tight all the time.

 

Let me tell you about a client. I’ll call him Carlos. Carlos runs a concrete crew up here in the Central Valley. He makes about $3.6 million a year. Good operator. He thought his payroll was about $95,000 a month, and that’s what the books said. When we rebuilt the real number, it looked like this. Gross wages: $95,000. Employer payroll taxes: $9,000. Benefits: $6,500. Workers’ comp added up to $3,000. Reimbursements and other stuff added up to $2,000. So the real payroll cost was about $115,500. A $20,000 gap every month. That’s $246,000 a year of profit that never existed.

 

So see what he was doing? He was bidding jobs based on the wrong number. He was paying himself based on the wrong number. Everything was wrong.

 

Stop for a second. If there is only one number you remember from this video, this is the number. Every dollar you pay in wages costs you $1.20, sometimes $1.30. If you bid a job at $30 an hour for labor, your real cost is $36. Do that math. $6 an hour, every hour, every job, across a year. That’s where your profits went, and that’s why your cash is leaking.

 

Let me show you how to fix it right now. There’s one number every builder should know. It’s called labor burden. Don’t worry about the term. I just want to give you the straight math and make it simple to figure out. You take everything you spend on payroll except wages. So set the wages aside and take everything else you spend: taxes, benefits, workers’ comp. Add all of that up, and divide it by gross wages. That’s your labor burden percent.

 

For Carlos, it was 21.6%. Every dollar of wages actually cost him $1.22. Once he knew that number, he could bid jobs the right way. He could hire the right way. He could pay himself and stop getting surprised.

 

So here’s what I want you to do. Three steps. Carlos didn’t know his labor burden either.

 

Step number one: figure out this number, because it’s a very important number. Pull last month’s payroll report. Add everything up: wages, employer taxes, benefits, workers’ comp, everything on that report. Then divide the non-wage stuff by the wages. That’s your labor burden percent. If you didn’t know it before, now you know it. You were guessing before, but now you have the number in front of you.

 

Number two: separate field labor from admin labor in your books. Field labor goes to job costs, and that’s part of your cost of goods sold. Admin and office go to overhead. Two different things. If everything is mixed together, you don’t actually know if your jobs are profitable. You’re just flying blind.

 

Three: track overtime weekly, not monthly. Every week, look at the overtime number, and every week ask yourself: why did we have overtime this week? Was it bad scheduling? Trades running late? Rework? Hours we underestimated and didn’t budget for? If you label the reason, you can fix the reason. But if you ignore it, overtime just becomes your new normal, your profits start disappearing, and your cash keeps leaking.

 

Hey, I want to thank you so much for sticking with me today. I know payroll is boring stuff, but it’s where the money is hiding. If you want help fixing this in your business, comment the word “payroll” below this video, and I’ll send you the first step based on your situation.

 

I’m Samy Basta. I run Basta & Company, a San Francisco based accounting firm. We work with builders all across California. All remote, all human. There are no phone trees. You’ll get to talk to a human if you call. If you want my team to look at your numbers and find your real payroll cost, book a complimentary consultation. The link is down below. And if that helped, hit subscribe, because I make a new video every week for California businesses. Thank you so much again. I’ll talk to you soon.

 

This has been another episode of our tax-saving video series. If you enjoyed this video, please like it, subscribe below, and share it with other business owners. You can find previous episodes and more information at bastacpa.com. Thanks for listening, and have a great day.

Episode Insights and Action Items

1. Payroll is more than the wages line.What’s happening: Real payroll cost is wages plus employer taxes, benefits, workers’ comp, reimbursements, overtime, and everything else that gets buried in the books. Most builders only look at wages.

2. The gap is often 15% to 30%.What’s happening: In Samy’s example, $70,000 of gross wages really costs about $85,000 to $91,000. When the books mix office and field wages and scatter workers’ comp and health insurance across accounts, the reports look fine but hide the gap.

3. A hidden gap leaks into every bid.What’s happening: If every wage dollar really costs $1.20, a job bid at $30 an hour of labor actually costs $36. That $6 an hour, on every hour of every job, is where profit disappears.

4. You can’t fix what you can’t see.What’s happening: One contractor’s gap of roughly $20,000 a month added up to $246,000 a year of profit that never existed. He was bidding jobs and paying himself off the wrong number.

 

ACTION ITEMS

1. Run the quick test.Multiply this month’s gross wages by 1.2. If the result makes you uncomfortable, you’ve found why cash feels tight.

2. Calculate your labor burden.From last month’s payroll report, divide everything except wages by gross wages. Do you know your number today?

3. Split field labor from office labor, and review overtime weekly.Field wages go to job costs, office wages go to overhead. Every week, ask why you had overtime and label the reason.

The Three Steps, in Plain English

Samy’s fix starts with one number, labor burden, and three habits that keep payroll from quietly eating your margin.

What Every Wage Dollar Really Costs

Samy compares payroll to ordering a pizza. You think it costs $20, but by the time delivery, tips, and extras are added, it’s closer to $40. Payroll works the same way: the wages line is only the start.

His rule of thumb is that every dollar of wages costs you about $1.20, sometimes $1.30. Want a quick gut check? Multiply this month’s gross wages by 1.2. If that number surprises you, you’ve just found why cash always feels tight.

That gap flows straight into your bids. Price labor at the wage rate alone, and you lose money on every hour you sell.

Labor priced in a bid
Real cost at $1.20 per wage dollar
$30 an hour
$36 an hour
Gap on every hour
$6
$70,000 of monthly gross wages
About $85,000 to $91,000 (Samy's estimate)

Step 1: Calculate Your Labor Burden

Labor burden is the one number Samy wants every builder to know. Pull last month’s payroll report and add up everything on it: wages, employer payroll taxes, benefits, workers’ comp, and reimbursements.

Then set the wages aside, add up everything else, and divide that total by gross wages. The result is your labor burden percentage. If yours is 21.6%, every dollar of wages really costs you $1.22.

Once you know it, you stop guessing. You can bid jobs, plan hiring, and set your own pay on the real number.

Step 2: Separate Field Labor from Office Labor

Field labor belongs in job costs, as part of cost of goods sold. Admin and office labor belong in overhead. They are two different things, and they need to live in different places in your books.

When they’re mixed together, you can’t tell whether your jobs are actually profitable. You’re flying blind, and job reports that look healthy may be hiding labor that was never charged to the work.

Step 3: Track Overtime Weekly, Not Monthly

Look at overtime every week and ask one question: why did we have overtime this week? Bad scheduling, trades running late, rework, or hours that were underestimated and never budgeted for.

If you label the reason, you can fix the reason. Ignore it, and overtime quietly becomes the new normal while profit disappears and cash keeps leaking.

Carlos and the $246,000 That Didn't Exist

This is the client story Samy shares in the episode. “Carlos” is not the client’s real name.

Carlos runs a concrete crew in California’s Central Valley, with about $3.6 million a year in revenue. Busy, always slammed, a good operator, but cash was always tight. His books showed payroll of about $95,000 a month.

When Samy’s team rebuilt the real number, payroll came to about $115,500 a month. That gap, roughly $20,000 every month, added up to $246,000 a year of profit he thought he had but didn’t. His labor burden was 21.6%.

He had been bidding jobs and paying himself based on wages alone. Knowing his labor burden let him bid, hire, and pay himself on the real number.

Monthly payroll
Amount
Gross wages
$95,000
Employer payroll taxes
$9,000
Benefits
$6,500
Workers' comp
$3,000
Reimbursements and other
$2,000
Real payroll cost
About $115,500
Labor burden
21.6%

4 Reasons for Overtime to Label Every Week

1

Bad scheduling

Crews were booked in the wrong order or overlapped, so hours piled up at the end of the week.

2

Trades running late

Another trade fell behind, and your crew paid for the wait.

3

Rework

Work had to be redone, and every redo hour is an unbilled hour.

4

Underestimated hours

The job took more hours than the estimate budgeted for.

Bottom Line

Payroll is boring, but it’s where the money is hiding. Know your labor burden, keep field and office labor separate, and look at overtime every week. Then bid, hire, and pay yourself on the real cost of every wage dollar, not the wages line alone.

Want my team to find your real payroll cost? Book a call with me. We work with builders all across California, all remote and all human, and we’ll help you see where your profit is really going.

ABOUT THE SPEAKER

Samy Basta, CPA

Founder, Basta & Company

 

Samy has over 25 years of experience in tax strategy, financial planning, and business advisory, with particular expertise in construction, architecture, and interior design. He hosts Basta & Company’s tax-saving video series, where he explains the rules California business owners actually run into, in plain English.

Labor burden is everything you spend on payroll beyond gross wages, including employer payroll taxes, benefits, workers’ comp, and reimbursements, expressed as a percentage of gross wages.

Pull last month’s payroll report, add up every non-wage cost, and divide that total by gross wages. In Samy’s example, Carlos’s labor burden was 21.6%, so every dollar of wages really cost him about $1.22.

Samy’s rule of thumb is $1.20 to $1.30 for every dollar of wages, or a 15% to 30% gap. Your own number depends on your benefits, workers’ comp rates, and payroll setup, so calculate it from your payroll report.

Yes. Field labor belongs in job costs as part of cost of goods sold, and office labor belongs in overhead. Mixing them makes it impossible to tell whether your jobs are profitable.

If you price labor at wages alone, you underbid every hour. With a 20% labor burden, a $30-an-hour labor rate really costs $36, so that $6 has to be in the bid.

Fill out our contact form to share your business details and biggest financial challenges. We’ll review everything, and if it looks like a good fit, we’ll invite you for a call to dive deeper. No obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Still Have A Question?

We’re here to help. Reach out to our team and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Sounds like a fit? Let's talk.

Basta & Company guides San Francisco businesses through every financial milestone — from business structure and accounting systems to tax strategy and scaling with confidence.