Safe Harbor Doesn't Mean What You Think: Why You Can Pay Every Quarter and Still Owe $40,000

Tax-Saving Video Series · With Samy Basta, CPA

In this episode, Samy explains why a business owner can make every quarterly tax payment and still owe $40,000 at tax time. When estimated payments are based on last year’s profit and the business grows, the payments fall behind. He walks through a contractor whose profit jumped from $220,000 to $400,000, explains why safe harbor protects you from penalties but not from the bill, and shares two steps to keep your tax plan in step with your growth.

Jump to: Episode insights · The two steps · David’s $40,000 surprise

Lightly edited for readability: speech-to-text errors corrected, wording unchanged.

 

You made every quarterly tax payment. You paid in April. You paid in June. You paid the next one, too. So why is your CPA telling you that you still owe $40,000? Here’s the reason. Your business grew, but your tax plan didn’t grow with it.

 

A lot of business owners think, “Hey, I made every payment, so I must be covered.” But that’s not always true. Your payments may be based on what you earned last year, but you’re paying taxes on what you earned this year. And if your business is growing fast, those numbers can be very different.

 

Maybe you’re a contractor who landed two large jobs at the end of the year. Maybe your property management company added more units. Maybe your architecture or design firm added several clients this year. Or maybe you’re an electrician, a plumber, a landscaper, whatever business you’re in, having your best year yet. Your income goes up, your profit goes up, but your tax payments stay the same. This is how a good year creates a bad surprise.

 

You may have heard the words “safe harbor,” which can help you avoid a penalty for not paying enough tax during the year. But safe harbor doesn’t mean your full tax bill is paid. It may protect you from a penalty. It doesn’t protect you from owing a lot of money. Those are two different things.

 

Let me give you a simple example. Let’s call this business owner David. David owns a construction company. Last year, his business made about $220,000 in profit. His quarterly tax payments were based mostly on last year’s tax return. David made every payment. He thought he was covered. Then David landed two large commercial jobs, revenue went up, and profit grew from $220,000 to $400,000. But his tax payments didn’t change.

 

So here’s what usually happens. David saw more money moving through the bank account, but he also had more payroll, more subs, more materials, higher insurance, and a new truck payment. And when extra cash was sitting in the bank, he used it. He bought equipment, he made a down payment, and he took a larger draw. Then his CPA updated the tax projection. David had paid about $55,000, but his expected tax this year, because of his growing business, is now closer to $95,000. So he was short about $40,000.

 

See, David didn’t miss a payment. The problem was that the payments were based on old numbers, and by the time he found out, the cash was already gone. That’s why this is not a tax problem. It’s a cash flow problem.


And here’s my honest opinion. Quarterly tax payments based on last year are not real tax planning. They’re a starting point. Your tax plan should change when your business changes.

 

Number one: compare your profit. Don’t only look at revenue. Look at your actual year-to-date profit, then compare it with the same time last year. If your profit is up 20%, 30%, or more, your current tax payments may be too low. Don’t wait until tax season to find out.

 

Number two: update your tax projection. Ask your CPA to use your current numbers, not only last year’s return. They should look at your current-year profit, your payroll, your owner draws, your other income, your equipment purchases, and what you expect for the rest of the year. The projection will not be perfect. It doesn’t need to be perfect. It just needs to be close enough so you can protect your cash.

 

A large tax bill is not always bad. It may mean you had a profitable year. But a large tax bill you didn’t plan for can hurt the business. So ask your CPA this question: are my tax payments based on last year, or on what I’m actually making this year? And ask one more question: how much cash should I set aside if the business keeps growing at this pace?

 

If your profit is up more than 20%, don’t wait until the return is prepared. Book a tax planning call with us, it’s a free call, or with your CPA if you have one. We’ll review your current numbers, estimate what may be coming, and help you make a plan before the cash is gone. Your business changed. Your tax plan should change, too. So schedule a call with us. Thank you so much for watching. I’ll see you in the next one.

 

This has been another episode of our tax-saving video series. If you enjoyed this video, please like it, subscribe below, and share it with other business owners. You can find previous episodes and more information at bastacpa.com. Thanks for listening, and have a great day.

Episode Insights and Action Items

1. Paying every quarter doesn’t mean you’re covered.What’s happening: Estimated payments are often based on last year’s income, but you owe tax on this year’s. In a fast-growing year, the gap can be large.

2. Safe harbor protects you from penalties, not from the bill.What’s happening: Meeting a safe harbor can help you avoid an underpayment penalty, but you still owe the full tax when you file.

3. It’s a cash flow problem, not just a tax problem.What’s happening: When extra cash sits in the bank, it gets spent on equipment, down payments, and larger draws. By the time the projection is updated, the money is gone.

4. A big tax bill can be good news, if you planned for it.What’s happening: A large bill may mean you had a profitable year. The damage comes when it’s a surprise and the cash has already been spent.

 

ACTION ITEMS

1. Compare year-to-date profit with last year.Look at profit, not revenue. Is it up 20% or more from the same point last year?

2. Ask your CPA for an updated projection.Are your payments based on last year, or on what you’re actually making this year?

3. Set cash aside as you grow.Ask how much to hold back if the business keeps growing at this pace, and keep it where it won’t get spent.

The Two Steps, in Plain English

Samy’s view is that quarterly payments based on last year are a starting point, not a tax plan. These two steps keep your plan in step with your business.

Why Your Payments Fall Behind When You Grow

Many owners set estimated payments from last year’s tax return. That’s a reasonable starting point, but you’re taxed on what you earn this year. When a contractor lands two big jobs, a property manager adds units, or a design firm signs several new clients, profit can jump while the payments stay the same.

That’s how a good year turns into a bad surprise at tax time.

What you might assume
What's actually true
I made every payment, so I'm covered
Payments based on last year can fall far short of this year's tax
Safe harbor means my taxes are paid
Safe harbor can help you avoid a penalty, but you still owe the balance
More cash in the bank means I can spend it
Part of that cash may be owed to the IRS and the FTB

Safe Harbor: Protection From Penalties, Not From the Bill

You may have heard that paying a “safe harbor” amount protects you. It can protect you from an underpayment penalty.

But safe harbor doesn’t mean your full tax bill is paid. If your profit jumped, you can meet the safe harbor and still owe a large balance when you file. Those are two different things.

Step 1: Compare Your Profit, Not Just Revenue

Look at your actual profit year to date, then compare it with the same point last year. Revenue can rise while margins shrink, so profit is the number that matters for tax.

If profit is up 20%, 30%, or more, your current payments may be too low. Don’t wait until tax season to find out.

Step 2: Update Your Tax Projection

Ask your CPA to build a projection from your current numbers, not only last year’s return. That means current-year profit, payroll, owner draws, other income, equipment purchases, and what you expect for the rest of the year.

It won’t be perfect, and it doesn’t need to be. It just needs to be close enough to protect your cash. Two questions to ask: are my payments based on last year or on what I’m making now, and how much cash should I set aside if we keep growing at this pace?

David's $40,000 Surprise

This is the example Samy walks through in the episode. “David” is an illustrative name.

David owns a construction company that made about $220,000 in profit last year. His quarterly payments were based mostly on that year’s tax return, and he made every one. Then he landed two large commercial jobs, and profit grew to about $400,000.

More money was moving through the bank, but so were more payroll, subs, materials, insurance, and a new truck payment. When extra cash sat in the account, he used it on equipment, a down payment, and a larger draw. When his CPA updated the projection, David had paid about $55,000 against an expected tax of about $95,000. He was about $40,000 short, and the cash was already gone.

David's numbers
Amount
Profit last year
About $220,000
Profit this year
About $400,000
Estimated tax paid
About $55,000
Expected tax this year
About $95,000
Shortfall
About $40,000

4 Signs Your Tax Payments May Be Too Low

1

Profit is up 20% or more

Compared with the same point last year.

2

You landed big new work

Large jobs, new units, or several new clients.

3

Payments are based on last year

No one has updated your projection this year.

4

Extra cash is getting spent

Equipment, down payments, and larger draws are adding up.

Bottom Line

Your business changed, so your tax plan should change too. A large tax bill isn’t always bad news; it may mean you had a great year. The problem is a bill you didn’t plan for, after the cash is already gone.

If your profit is up more than 20%, don’t wait until your return is prepared. Book a call with me and we’ll review your current numbers, estimate what’s coming, and help you make a plan before the cash is gone.

ABOUT THE SPEAKER

Samy Basta, CPA

Founder, Basta & Company

 

Samy has over 25 years of experience in tax strategy, financial planning, and business advisory, with particular expertise in construction, architecture, and interior design. He hosts Basta & Company’s tax-saving video series, where he explains the rules California business owners actually run into, in plain English.

Estimated payments are often based on last year’s income. If your profit grew this year, those payments may cover far less than the tax you actually owe.

Safe harbor can help you avoid a penalty for not paying enough tax during the year. But as Samy explains, it doesn’t mean your full tax bill is paid. It may protect you from a penalty; it doesn’t protect you from owing a lot of money.

Compare your year-to-date profit with the same point last year. If it’s up 20% or more, ask your CPA to update your tax projection.

Current-year profit, payroll, owner draws, other income, equipment purchases, and what you expect for the rest of the year.

It depends on your profit, entity type, and state. Ask your CPA how much to set aside if your business keeps growing at its current pace, and keep that cash separate so it doesn’t get spent.

Fill out our contact form to share your business details and biggest financial challenges. We’ll review everything, and if it looks like a good fit, we’ll invite you for a call to dive deeper. No obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Still Have A Question?

We’re here to help. Reach out to our team and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Sounds like a fit? Let's talk.

Basta & Company guides San Francisco businesses through every financial milestone — from business structure and accounting systems to tax strategy and scaling with confidence.