California S-Corp Strategy for Contractors: When the Election Actually Saves Money

Tax-Saving Video Series · With Samy Basta, CPA

In this episode, Samy explains what an S corp election really is, how it changes the way you pay yourself, and why the savings aren’t automatic. Using a simple $120,000 profit example, he shows how a roughly $6,000 payroll tax difference shrinks once you subtract payroll costs, an extra tax return, and California’s franchise tax. Then he shares the four checks he uses to decide whether the election makes sense.

Jump to: Episode insights · The four checks · The $120,000 example

Lightly edited for readability: speech-to-text errors corrected, wording unchanged.

 

Let me ask you something. Your business is making good money. You’re busy. You’re working hard. But every year you look at the tax bill and think, “How am I paying this much?” I hear that all the time. And sometimes the problem isn’t a missing deduction. It’s the way your business is taxed. That’s where an S corp may help. Not for everybody, but for the right business, it can save real money.

 

So what exactly is an S corp? Let me make it simple. For many business owners, it’s just a tax choice. It’s a tax election. You may not have to close your LLC. You may not have to convert your LLC to an S corp. You may not have to start a new company. Your customers don’t change. Your work doesn’t change. You’re simply asking the IRS to tax the business differently.

 

And the biggest change is how you pay yourself. With an S corp, the money is usually split into two buckets. The first bucket is your salary. That’s your paycheck for the work you do. The second bucket is the remaining business profit that comes to you as a distribution. Now let me be clear. The distribution is not tax-free. You still have to pay income tax on it. But generally, you don’t pay Social Security and Medicare on that distribution. And that’s where the possible savings come from.

 

Let me give you a simple example. Say your business makes $120,000 before paying your salary. You work full-time in the business. You manage the projects. You talk to clients. You deal with the crew. You solve problems all day. So yes, the business needs to pay you a fair salary. Let’s say the salary is $70,000. That part goes through payroll. Then, after payroll taxes and other expenses, the remaining profit may come to you as a distribution. The rough payroll tax difference could be around $6,000.

 

But hold on. That doesn’t mean you save $6,000. Not yet. You have to subtract the extra costs. You’ve got payroll to run, a separate business tax return, accounting, bookkeeping, and tax preparation fees. And here in California, the S corp pays franchise tax, too. California generally charges 1.5% of the S corp’s net income, and in most cases there is an $800 minimum tax. So you have to look at the whole picture. Maybe the S corp saves you $5,000. Maybe it saves you $500. Maybe it saves you nothing. You have to do the math before you make the choice.

 

This is where people get into trouble. Someone online says, “Hey, open an S corp and save thousands.” So they do it, but the business is only making $50,000. Now they have payroll. They have another tax return to file, more paperwork, more accounting fees, and tax preparation fees. And after all that, they hardly save anything. That’s not tax planning. That’s just creating more work.

 

So when does an S corp start making sense? I usually look at four things. Number one: how much profit is the business making? Not revenue. I’m talking about profit, the bottom line of your P&L. For many owners, it starts looking serious at about $100,000. That’s not a magic number. Every business is different. But roughly when you get to low six figures, that’s when you need to consider the S corp election.

 

Number two: where is the profit coming from? Is it coming mainly from your work, your time, your skills, your relationships? If you’re creating most of the income yourself, your salary may need to be higher. You don’t pay yourself $20,000, take another $100,000 in distributions, and pretend you barely work there. The IRS doesn’t like this. They’re not going to buy that.

 

Number three: is the profit steady? Maybe you had one great year because you had a large project. That doesn’t always mean you need an S corp. It works better when the profit is steady and you can plan for payroll throughout the year.

 

Check number four: are you ready to run it correctly? You need to run payroll. You need clean books. You need reconciliations. You need another tax return. And you need to be ready to pay yourself a reasonable salary. It’s not difficult, but it’s real work that you have to factor into your decision.

 

And the salary is where a lot of business owners get too aggressive. You think, “Hey, the lower the salary, the more tax I save.” That’s not always true, and it’s not the right way to look at it. Your salary should make sense based on what you do, how many hours you work, your experience, and what somebody else would earn doing the same job. The goal is not to play games with the IRS, because that can get you into a messy audit. The goal is to use the rules correctly for your benefit and, at the same time, optimize and maximize your tax savings.

 

There’s one more thing. An S corp also affects your qualified business income deduction, the QBI deduction. Your salary doesn’t count as QBI. So again, you cannot look only at the payroll tax savings. You have to look at everything together: federal income tax, payroll taxes, California franchise tax, the QBI deduction, and the cost of running the S corp as a whole.

 

So the question is, should you become an S corp? Maybe. If the profit is strong, the profit is steady, you actively work in the business, and the savings are greater than the extra costs, then yes, it could be a very smart move. But if the profit is still low or unpredictable, you probably have to wait. You don’t need an S corp just because you have an LLC, and you don’t need one because somebody on social media told you to get one.

 

So here’s what I want you to do this week. Pull your profit and loss statement. Go to the bottom section, the net profit. Not the revenue, not your sales, not your bank balance. Look at the net profit at the bottom of the P&L. Then ask yourself: if I paid myself a fair salary, would there still be enough profit to make the S corp worthwhile? That is the real question. And don’t wait until tax season to look at it. S corp elections have deadlines. It’s better to plan early than to try to fix it later.

 

And if you want me to look at the numbers with you, I’ll tell you straight. Maybe an S corp will save you money, maybe it won’t. Either way, you’ll know before making the decision. I’m Samy Basta. Thanks for watching. And if you want help deciding whether an S corp makes sense for your business, book a free call. Happy to talk to you.

 

This has been another episode of our tax-saving video series. If you enjoyed this video, please like it, subscribe below, and share it with other business owners. You can find previous episodes and more information at bastacpa.com. Thanks for listening, and have a great day.

Episode Insights and Action Items

1. An S corp is a tax election, not a new business.What’s happening: For many owners, you keep your LLC, your customers, and your work. You’re simply asking the IRS to tax the business differently.

2. Distributions aren’t tax-free.What’s happening: You still pay income tax on them. The savings come from generally not paying Social Security and Medicare taxes on profit you take as a distribution instead of salary.

3. Payroll tax savings aren’t your real savings.What’s happening: In Samy’s example, a roughly $6,000 payroll tax difference has to cover payroll, a separate tax return, accounting fees, and California’s 1.5% franchise tax with an $800 minimum. The net could be $5,000, $500, or nothing.

4. A salary that’s too low is a red flag.What’s happening: Your salary should reflect what you do, your hours, your experience, and what someone else would earn doing the same job. Paying yourself $20,000 and taking $100,000 in distributions invites IRS trouble.

 

ACTION ITEMS

1. Pull your P&L and find your net profit.Not revenue, not your bank balance. Is it in the low six figures or higher?

2. Ask the real question.If you paid yourself a fair salary, would enough profit be left to make the S corp worth the extra cost?

3. Plan before the deadline.S corp elections have deadlines. Run the numbers with your CPA early instead of trying to fix it later.

The Four Checks, in Plain English

Samy looks at four things before recommending an S corp election, and then he runs the whole picture, not just the payroll tax savings.

What an S Corp Election Is: Salary Plus Distributions

For many business owners, an S corp is simply a tax election. You may not need to close your LLC, convert it, or start a new company. Your customers and your work stay the same. You’re asking the IRS to tax the business differently.

The biggest change is how you pay yourself. The first bucket is a salary for the work you do, paid through payroll with payroll taxes. The second bucket is the remaining profit, which comes to you as a distribution. Distributions still carry income tax, but they generally aren’t subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. That’s where the possible savings come from.

What changes
What stays the same
How the IRS taxes the business
Your customers
How you pay yourself: salary plus distributions
Your work
Payroll, a separate business return, and California franchise tax
For many owners, your existing LLC

Checks 1 and 2: How Much Profit, and Where It Comes From

How much profit? Look at net profit, the bottom line of your P&L, not revenue. For many owners, Samy starts looking seriously at an S corp around $100,000 of profit. It’s not a magic number, but it’s roughly where the math can start to work.

Where does it come from? If most of the profit comes from your own work, time, skills, and relationships, your salary may need to be higher, which leaves less in distributions and less in savings.

Checks 3 and 4: Steady Profit and Readiness to Run It

Is the profit steady? One great year from a large project doesn’t always mean you need an S corp. It works better when profit is steady and you can plan payroll throughout the year.

Are you ready to run it correctly? That means running payroll, keeping clean books, reconciling accounts, filing another tax return, and paying yourself a reasonable salary. It isn’t difficult, but it’s real work to factor into the decision.

Reasonable Salary and the QBI Deduction

The salary is where many owners get too aggressive. A lower salary isn’t automatically better. It should make sense based on what you do, your hours, your experience, and what someone else would earn doing the same job. Playing games with it can lead to a messy audit.

An S corp also affects the qualified business income (QBI) deduction, because your salary doesn’t count as QBI. That’s why Samy looks at everything together: federal income tax, payroll taxes, California franchise tax, the QBI deduction, and the cost of running the S corp.

The $120,000 Example: Why $6,000 Isn't Your Real Savings

This is the simple example Samy walks through in the episode. It’s an illustration, not a client.

The business makes $120,000 before paying the owner. The owner works full-time, managing projects, talking to clients, and dealing with the crew, so the business needs to pay a fair salary. Say that’s $70,000, run through payroll. After payroll taxes and other expenses, the remaining profit can come out as a distribution.

The rough payroll tax difference is about $6,000. But that isn’t the savings yet. Subtract the cost of payroll, a separate business tax return, accounting and tax prep fees, and California’s franchise tax. The real savings could be $5,000, $500, or nothing.

And at only $50,000 of profit, Samy warns, owners often take on all that extra work and hardly save anything.

Samy's example
Amount
Profit before owner's salary
$120,000
Owner's salary through payroll
$70,000
Rough payroll tax difference
About $6,000
California franchise tax
1.5% of net income, $800 minimum in most cases
Other added costs
Payroll, a separate return, accounting and tax prep fees
Possible net savings
$5,000, $500, or nothing

4 Checks Before You Elect S Corp Status

1

Profit level

Is net profit roughly in the low six figures or higher?

2

Source of profit

If it comes mostly from your own work, your salary may need to be higher.

3

Steady profit

One big project year isn’t enough. Can you plan payroll all year?

4

Ready to run it

Payroll, clean books, reconciliations, another return, and a reasonable salary.

Bottom Line

An S corp can be a very smart move when profit is strong and steady, you actively work in the business, and the savings beat the extra cost. If profit is still low or unpredictable, you probably need to wait. You don’t need one just because you have an LLC, or because someone on social media said so.

Want a straight answer for your business? Book a call with me and we’ll run the numbers with you. Maybe an S corp saves you money, maybe it won’t. Either way, you’ll know before you decide.

ABOUT THE SPEAKER

Samy Basta, CPA

Founder, Basta & Company

 

Samy has over 25 years of experience in tax strategy, financial planning, and business advisory, with particular expertise in construction, architecture, and interior design. He hosts Basta & Company’s tax-saving video series, where he explains the rules California business owners actually run into, in plain English.

It’s a tax election that changes how the IRS taxes your business. You pay yourself a salary through payroll, and the remaining profit can come to you as distributions that generally aren’t subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Often not. Many LLCs can elect to be taxed as an S corp. As Samy puts it, it’s just a tax election. Your customers and your work don’t change.

Samy starts looking seriously around $100,000 of net profit, but it isn’t a magic number. The savings have to be greater than the added cost of payroll, an extra return, accounting fees, and California franchise tax.

California generally charges S corps a franchise tax of 1.5% of net income, with an $800 minimum in most cases.

Before tax season. As Samy says, S corp elections have deadlines, and it’s better to plan early than to try to fix it later. Run the numbers with your CPA ahead of time.

Fill out our contact form to share your business details and biggest financial challenges. We’ll review everything, and if it looks like a good fit, we’ll invite you for a call to dive deeper. No obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Still Have A Question?

We’re here to help. Reach out to our team and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Sounds like a fit? Let's talk.

Basta & Company guides San Francisco businesses through every financial milestone — from business structure and accounting systems to tax strategy and scaling with confidence.